We use privacy-friendly analytics — Plausible (cookieless) and Microsoft Clarity, which uses cookies for anonymized heatmaps and session insights — plus advertising tags (LinkedIn Insight Tag and Google Ads) to measure our advertising and show relevant Sydra ads. We never sell your data. See our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
No Surprises Act · Definition
Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) is the federal arbitration process for settling out-of-network payment disputes between healthcare providers and health plans. Created by the No Surprises Act and live since January 2022, it replaced balance billing for most emergency and facility-based care. When a payer pays less than a provider believes the service is worth, IDR is the mechanism that decides the amount — and the determination binds both sides.
It is deliberately not a negotiation. Each side submits one final offer, and a certified arbitrator must choose one of them outright. There is no middle ground, which changes how the offer should be built.
Source: CMS Federal IDR Public Use Files, calendar 2025.
Have a denied out-of-network claim?
Send one EOB. We'll tell you if it qualifies and what it's worth, in writing, within one business day.
IDR is a process problem rather than a legal mystery. The rules are fixed and published; what decides most disputes is whether each deadline was met.
Before anything can be arbitrated, the provider and the payer have a 30-business-day window to settle the amount between themselves. It starts the day the initial payment or denial arrives. Most disputes die here — not because the parties disagree, but because nobody opened the window in time.
If open negotiation ends without agreement, either side has four business days to initiate IDR and select a certified entity. Four business days is the tightest deadline in the process and the one most often missed.
The certified IDR entity checks that the claim actually qualifies — the right plan type, the right service, the deadlines met, the batching rules respected. Roughly 18% of initiated disputes are ruled ineligible, which is why screening before you file matters more than arguing well afterwards.
Both sides submit a single final offer with supporting evidence. The arbitrator must pick one of the two — there is no splitting the difference. That is what makes the offer itself a strategic decision rather than a formality.
Twenty-one states run their own out-of-network dispute processes, and which one applies turns on the patient's plan type rather than the procedure or the provider. Self-funded ERISA plans generally follow the federal process; state-regulated plans may follow the state's. Two patients can receive identical care at the same facility and their claims route differently, on different clocks.
See state IDR pathways for how each one works, or the federal process in detail.
Independent Dispute Resolution — the federal arbitration process created by the No Surprises Act for settling out-of-network payment disputes between providers and health plans. It replaced balance billing for most emergency and facility-based care.
Out-of-network providers, facilities and air ambulance services, for claims covered by the No Surprises Act — generally emergency services and non-emergency services delivered by out-of-network clinicians at in-network facilities. Whether a specific claim qualifies depends on the patient’s plan type, which is why eligibility is screened first.
No. An appeal asks the payer to reconsider its own decision. IDR takes the dispute to a neutral certified entity whose determination is binding on both parties. They are separate tracks with separate deadlines, and pursuing one does not preserve your right to the other.
Providers prevailed in roughly 88% of federal IDR determinations across the 2.18 million decisions published for calendar 2025. Win rates vary considerably by procedure code and payer — the per-code record is published on each of our CPT pages.
There is an administrative fee per party plus the certified entity’s fee, which the losing party pays. The administrative fee dropped substantially for 2026. The larger cost for most practices is staff time, which is the part software addresses.
Send one denied EOB. We will tell you whether it is eligible, whether the window is still open, and what it is worth — before you commit to anything.
Medically & clinically reviewed by Dr. John M. Abrahams, MD
Board-certified neurosurgeon and founder of Sydra · Last reviewed September 2026 · About the author
Figures reflect the published federal record across all disputes, not a prediction about any individual claim. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.
No outcome is guaranteed. Results vary by claim, payer, specialty, and documentation. Figures reflect the published federal record across all disputes, not a prediction about any individual claim. This is general information, not legal or financial advice.